Does “Fighting Spirit” Affect Health?

James S. Gordon, MDCancer0 Comments

By James S. Gordon MD

Richard Sloan’s op-ed in the New York Times (“A fighting spirit won’t save your life”, January 25, 2011) is guilty of precisely the faults he attributes to those who believe that attitude can affect health – smug, self-righteous, and short on scientific evidence.

Prof. Sloan is of course correct when he takes to task those who believe that “requests to the universe” ensure good health, or that good people always receive good prognoses. But these are extremes, rhetorical straw men. There have in fact been years of important scientific investigations on the very real benefits of hopefulness and positive expectation.

Here are several examples: a 15 year follow-up of Steven Greer’s landmark study showed that a fighting spirit didn’t, over the long haul, enhance survival for women with advanced breast cancer; on the other hand, the follow-up did demonstrate that feelings of helplessness and hopelessness significantly decreased longevity. Contrary to what Prof. Sloan suggests, the pioneering work of Redford Williams and others has clearly shown connections between hostility and heart disease. And a number of investigations over 20 years have demonstrated that people with lung cancer who are more optimistic actually have better prognoses than those with a similar stage of disease and physical findings who are less sanguine.

Prof. Sloan does a disservice to readers and to the truth when he categorically denies the power of hope in healing.

About the Author
James S. Gordon, MD

James S. Gordon, MD

Website Twitter LinkedIn Instagram

James S. Gordon, MD is Founder and Director of The Center for Mind-Body Medicine; Clinical Professor, Department of Psychiatry and Family Medicine; Georgetown University School of Medicine and author of Manifesto for a New Medicine, Comprehensive Cancer Care, and Unstuck: Your Guide to the Seven Stage Journey out of Depression.

Related Posts

Journeying through Breast Cancer with CMBM Diagnosed with cancer I, like many other cancer patients, was thrown into the dizzying world of doctors, hospitals, MRIs, biopsies, surgery, chemo and...
Coming Together at CancerGuides Israel By James S. Gordon MDPeople with cancer often come to me with a central question: “What else can I do?” This has two parts: What other therapies are...
Our work in Israel and Gaza in Jerusalem By James S. Gordon MDHi everybody,I hope you've all been enjoying your summers. I've been  in Israel and Gaza with our team, and more recently hav...
A Better Litmus Test for Healthcare Reform By James S. Gordon MDDavid Leonhardt’s “prostate cancer test” (The New York Times, July 8, 2009) is a good but incomplete one for healthcare reform....